July 28, 2009 at 7:41 pm 1 comment

It’s always nice to have a nice, comfortable, light-hearted morning in which you LEARN SOMETHING!  It was also very nice to be up and about, although by the time we got to the last group “activity” I was really hoping it wouldn’t be another group write and present – very pleasantly surprised to find that it wasn’t. 

One thing I’ve noticed, and maybe others can fill me in here, is how much learning I’m doing from watching Judith, Bill and other present, facilitate and educate.  As a fairly new teacher, I find myself spending a lot of time focusing on observing what they are doing in class, observing class reaction, and trying to adapt and integrate into my own professional practice.  I also find myself being, at times, overly critical of what I observe – I wonder if this is endemic to only new teachers (as I is… *grammar*), or to anyone with experience in the education field who has had the opportunity to be facing to and from the “blackboard”, or going even further – do other students, who may not teach, feel the same?  Does the fact that I’m an educator lead to my assumption that I’m more justified in my critiques than say a business student or science student?

Anyways, I digress.  I’ve spent many hours going through the grad transition process for high school students, and often thought about what our specific grad transition package contains.  From memory, the students did have to complete an online version of the MBTI, and record what it said about them.  I also remember passing the whole thing off as a bunch of “mumbo jumbo”.  WOW.  Oops.

I’m not sure what effect today had on me, although I do know it has made me aware of who I am, and more willing to own up to who I am (not 100% completely though…).  I’m forced to imagine how the lives of the these high school students would be changed or enhanced if we not only got them to complete the survey, but put them through an activity such as was done today.  The survey was interesting, but the my understanding of what the designations meant, and how they were significant to me, was really cemented through the activities. 

I definitely have a new understanding of myself that I can bring to the table when starting projects, either individually or with a group.  I wonder how the lives of graduating students would be affected if they not only left knowing their true identity (according to the MBTI), but also had begun to develop a deeper understanding of what it all means?  How would their interpersonal relationships be changed and challenged?  How would their approach to school work, jobs, and other required tasks be enhanced or diminished?  Would there be any change at all, or is it only because I’ve had enough life experiences that the MBTI and its associated activities were significant to me? (Were they significant to anyone else?)


Entry filed under: Personal Development & Insight.

Bloodletting & Miraculous Cures

1 Comment Add your own

  • 1. sharimck  |  July 29, 2009 at 1:59 am

    Hi Robb, I left today’s MBTI session with some similar thoughts. Although I may be only approaching the halfway mark (39 years) in my life, I have considerably more significant and formative life experiences than a high school grad might. Our personality preferences wouldn’t change from high school to middle age, but there may be two significant differences that set adults apart from youth when examining usefulness of the MBTI.

    The first would be the work we’ve done in overcoming and compensating for some of our leanings; for example, I am an introvert (100% percent ‘I’, 0% ‘E’) but a large part of my job is public speaking. This is certainly not the realm where I feel most comfortable – but within my professional life I’ve not only forced this to happen, I’ve become fairly good at it, and now I may be the first to volunteer to stand up in front of an audience. This came about through self-reflection and a desire to improve an aspect of myself that was holding me back professionally. An introverted high school student may have just begun this process; worked up the courage to speak to a girl, for instance.

    The second difference I see is in our ability as adults to have an ongoing consciousness about others and to not only maintain tolerance for other personality preferences, but to see them as strengths and build upon them. I think we are just starting to do this ourselves as we spend time working within groups during this residency to achieve a common goal. We’ll begin to use each others’ strengths and weaknesses to reach a purpose as effectively as possible. I’m not sure if this awareness would be able to develop in a high school student, who is just working out who they are and how they can make their way in the world.

    I do agree that the MBTI would be a useful experience for them as they near graduation – as the ability to ‘know oneself’ is invaluable to personal growth. It would be interesting to have a deeper look into the literature to see if MBTI is succesful in guiding high school students towards suitable career paths. I see room for both quantitative and qualitative research here!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Trackback this post  |  Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed

Twitter Updates

Error: Twitter did not respond. Please wait a few minutes and refresh this page.

%d bloggers like this: